HR decision log

Record why you made every people decision, in a way that holds up.

Warnings, dismissals, promotions, pay changes, probation outcomes and accommodation requests. HRDocket asks the questions an outsider would ask, attaches evidence from the employee’s file, checks for gaps, and locks the record with every version kept.

  • No credit card
  • Free setup help
  • Plans from $19 a month
Why it matters

The letter shows what you decided. It rarely shows why.

Months later, someone asks you to explain a decision. By then the facts are in old emails, the manager may have left, and nobody remembers what was weighed.

THE CLAIM

“I was never given a chance to explain”

A dismissed employee brings a claim. You know you held a meeting, but there is no note of what was said or who was there.

THE PROMOTION

“Why her and not me?”

An internal candidate asks how the decision was made. The criteria were clear at the time. They were just never written down.

THE PAY REVIEW

Two similar roles, two different raises

Someone compares pay changes across the team. Without a record of the reasons, every difference looks like favouritism.

HRDocket records the reasons when the decision is made, so when someone asks why, you have the answer, the evidence and the date.

What you can record

Guided questions for every common people decision

Each decision type has its own built-in questions, the ones a lawyer, tribunal or auditor would ask. Reword them, reorder them, or add your own in Settings.

Warnings

What happened and when, the policy, first or repeat issue, warning level, and whether the employee was heard.

Dismissals

The reason, the policy breached, earlier warnings, the employee’s response, alternatives and the right to appeal.

Promotions

The criteria, evidence of performance, who else was considered, and whether the role was advertised.

Pay changes

The change and from when, the reason, and how it compares with similar roles.

Probation outcomes

Confirmed, extended or not confirmed, the objectives, extension terms and feedback given.

Accommodation decisions

What was requested, whether it was approved, partly approved or declined, and alternatives offered.

Any other decision

Record anything else you want on file, with questions you write yourself.

How it works

From decision to defensible record in four steps

Record the decision

From the Decision Log or the employee’s record: the type, what was decided, who decided and who was involved.

Answer the guided questions

Hints keep answers to facts, not opinions. Write a summary, or have one drafted from your answers only.

Check before you record

HRDocket flags missing dates, vague policies, missing evidence and whether the employee was heard. Fix now takes you to each field.

Lock it, keep every version

Recording freezes the decision. Changes become new versions with a reason. Download a PDF on your letterhead.

Recording a decision takes a few minutes. Generate a warning, dismissal or promotion letter and HRDocket offers to record the reasoning straight away.

Watch the tutorial

See the Decision Log in six minutes

Settings, recording a warning, the check before you record, amending a record and downloading the PDF.

Guided questions

The questions a tribunal would ask, asked first

Every decision type comes with questions written for someone outside your company reading the record later. Hints under each one keep the answer to dates and facts, and the policy question picks straight from your policy library.

  • Reword and reorder the built-in questions for each type
  • Add your own questions, such as “Was HR consulted?”
  • Summary drafted from your answers only, for you to read and edit
Record a decision: Warning
What happened, and when?
Give the dates. Describe what the employee did, not your opinion of them.
Late on 3, 5 and 10 November 2026, by 25 to 40 minutes.
Which policy or standard applies?
Employee Handbook, section 4.2 Attendance and punctuality
Warning level
VerbalFirst writtenFinal written
Was the employee given a chance to respond, and what did they say?
Yes. Meeting on 17 November with Danny Lee. Chris said bus delays; we offered a 9:30am start.
Example data
Check before you record

See the gaps a lawyer would see, while you can still fix them

Before a decision is frozen, HRDocket reads it the way someone outside your company would. Each flag says what is missing, and Fix now takes you to the exact field.

  • No dates or instances given
  • A policy named too vaguely, such as “Handbook”
  • A repeat issue with no earlier warning attached
  • No record that the employee was heard

Flags never stop you. You decide, and you can still record anyway.

Check before you record
No earlier warning is attached. Attach it, or explain why there was none.Go to field
The record shows the employee was not heard. If they were, update the answer.Go to field
You did not give any dates or instances for the lateness.Go to field
You name only “Handbook” and do not identify the specific policy or rule.Go to field
Fix nowRecord anyway
Evidence from the employee’s file

Attach the proof without hunting for it

The employee’s record is already in HRDocket, so the evidence is one click away. Attach earlier decisions, policies they acknowledged, incidents, credentials and attendance, or upload meeting notes and emails.

  • Earlier warnings and decisions
  • Signed policies and documents
  • Entries from the incident log
  • Your own files, such as meeting notes
Evidence
Verbal warning for latenessEarlier decision · Nov 10, 2026
Attached
Employee HandbookPolicy acknowledged · Oct 2, 2026
Attached
Meeting notes, 17 Nov 2026.pdfUploaded file
Attached
+ Attach from file
Example data
Locked and versioned

Built so nobody can quietly rewrite history

Recording freezes the decision. If something needs to change, Amend this record opens it for editing and asks why. The old version is kept, the new one becomes current, and the reason is saved in notes that can’t be edited later.

  • Every version kept, with who changed it and when
  • Mark sensitive decisions as restricted
  • Set a review in 30, 60 or 90 days to record how it worked out
  • Download a decision record PDF on your letterhead
Written warning for repeated lateness
WarningRestrictedAmended
Versions
V2
Version 2Frank Hanson · Nov 19, 2026
Current
V1
Version 1Frank Hanson · Nov 18, 2026
Kept
Note: “Effective date moved to 20 Nov.” Can’t be edited later.
Example data
Set it up your way

Your questions, your rules

In Settings, choose how your company records decisions. Two switches and a question list per decision type are all it takes.

  • Ask to record the reasoning after every warning, dismissal or promotion letter
  • Let managers record decisions for the people who report to them
  • Built-in questions can be reworded but not removed, because the check relies on them
Settings: Decision Log
Ask to record the reasoning after a decision letter
Managers can record decisions
Questions
WarningDismissalPromotionPay changeProbation outcomeAccommodationOther+ Add question
Everything included

A decision log built for HR documentation

Guided questions per type

Built-in questions for six decision types, plus Other.

Custom questions

Reword, reorder and add questions in Settings.

Summary drafting

A draft from your answers only, for you to read and edit.

Check before you record

Gaps flagged, with Fix now to jump to each field.

Evidence from the file

Decisions, policies, incidents, credentials, attendance and uploads.

Locked records

Recording freezes the decision. Drafts stay editable.

Version history

Amendments become new versions, with the reason kept.

Restricted records

Keep sensitive decisions to the people who need them.

Review dates

30, 60 or 90 days, or a date you pick.

PDF on your letterhead

A clean decision record, ready to send.

Similar cases on dismissals

Earlier decisions like this one, to check consistency.

Prompt after letters

Record the reasoning right after generating a letter.

Manager recording

Managers record for their own reports, if you allow it.

Record for several employees

Repeat a decision for another employee without retyping.

Decision Log view

Every decision across the company in one list.

Who it’s for

For teams that may one day have to explain a decision

Small businesses without HR

Owners and managers who make the calls and need them on record.

Teams with line managers

Managers record decisions for their own reports, the same way every time.

Healthcare and care

Conduct and capability decisions that regulators may review.

Schools, childcare and NGOs

Decisions boards, funders and inspectors may ask about.

Growing companies

Consistent promotions and pay changes as the team gets bigger.

Be ready before anyone asks

A letter in a folder records the outcome. HRDocket records the reasons.

Letters, emails and notesHRDocket Decision Log
The reasonsIn someone’s head or an old emailAnswered against guided questions, on the record
GapsFound by the other side’s lawyerFlagged before you record, while you can fix them
EvidenceScattered across inboxes and drivesAttached from the employee’s file
ChangesOverwritten, with no traceNew version, old one kept, reason noted
ConsistencyNobody can see past decisionsSimilar cases shown on dismissals
When someone asksDays of diggingA PDF record in seconds
Pricing

Priced by team size, not per employee

Every account starts with 7 days of the Business plan, free. No credit card needed.

Starter

$19 / month
  • Up to 15 employees
  • 120 AI credits a month
  • Document generator, e-signatures and employee records
Most teams

Growth

$49 / month
  • Up to 50 employees
  • 250 AI credits a month
  • Everything in Starter

Business

$99 / month
  • Up to 140 employees
  • 600 AI credits a month
  • Everything in Growth

Pay yearly and get 2 months free. A free plan is available for up to 3 employees. Compare all plans

Questions

Frequently asked questions

What is an HR decision log?

A record of the people decisions a company makes, such as warnings, dismissals, promotions and pay changes, with the reasons, who decided, who was involved, the evidence and the dates. It shows why a decision was made, not only what was decided.

How should HR document a disciplinary decision?

Record what happened and when, the specific policy or rule that applies, whether it is a first or repeat issue, any earlier warnings, whether the employee was given a chance to respond and what they said, who decided, and the outcome. Attach the evidence and keep the record unchanged once it is final. HRDocket’s warning and dismissal questions follow this structure.

How is this different from keeping the warning letter?

The letter tells the employee the outcome. The decision record shows how you got there: the facts, the policy, earlier warnings, whether the employee was heard, and who was involved. That is what people ask for when a decision is challenged.

Can I change a decision after it is recorded?

Yes, with Amend this record. You make the change and say why. The old version is kept, the new one becomes current, and your reason is saved in notes that can’t be edited later.

Can I change the questions?

Yes. In Settings, you can reword and reorder the built-in questions for each decision type and add your own. Built-in questions can’t be removed, because the check before you record relies on them.

Does AI write the decision record?

Only if you ask. Write summary drafts a summary from your answers only, and you read and edit it before using it. You can always write the summary yourself.

Does the check stop me from recording?

No. It points out what someone outside your company might notice, such as missing dates or evidence. You can fix each one with Fix now, or record anyway.

Who can see decision records?

Your HR team. You can let managers record decisions for the people who report to them, and mark sensitive records as restricted.

Can managers record decisions?

Yes, if you turn it on in Settings. Teammates with the Manager role can then record decisions for the people who report to them.

Does it work with the warning letters I generate?

Yes. After you generate a warning, dismissal, promotion or similar letter, HRDocket offers to record the reasoning straight away, so the letter and the decision record sit together on the employee’s record.

Is this legal advice?

No. HRDocket helps you keep a complete and consistent record. It does not decide whether a decision is lawful. For serious cases, speak to an employment lawyer and bring the record with you.

How long does setup take?

A few minutes. The built-in questions are ready to use, so you can record your first decision straight away and adjust the questions in Settings later. If you would rather not do it yourself, our team will set it up with you for free.

Start today

When someone asks why, have the answer.

Record your next warning, promotion or pay change with the reasons, the evidence and a locked record.

  • No credit card
  • Free setup help
  • Cancel any time

HRDocket helps you keep complete records. It is not legal advice.

HRDocket logo HRDocket